ValuedChange's Feedback Ratings History
From: Neverhadawinner ( 27 ) - February 11 2021 - 04:09 PM CST
I just received the 1898 S Quarter that was represented as Fine in quality. I have examined the coin under my LCD Ditigtal Microscope (2mega Pixel magnification) and find the obverse of the coin is at best a G4. The reverse is better but a coin's value is usually established by the obverse side. The Greysheet site establishes a retail value of a G4 at around $19. It also states the retail value of a F12 at around $54. I used the American Numismati Association Grading Standards Sixth Edition as my grading criteria. Looking at the obverse, the letters of "Liberty" were not present. An F12 would have all letters visible but weak. It is clear I over paid by $25 for this coin. It is my error in judgement. I will not probably make it again but not with this seller.
Reply by ValuedChange: Dear Charles,
We are sorry that you are not satisfied with your purchase. We would have appreciated the opportunity to "make this right" before you posted a negative review. It is the ONLY negative review we have received.
We will not contest your appraisal of this coin and we would like to offer you a full refund of the original purchase price and shipping cost. We would also cover the cost of returning the coin to us.
Please ship the coin to us with "Tracking". Notify us (via this site) that the coin is on the way and advise us of the tracking number and shipping cost. When we receive the coin, we will send you all of the funds that you have invested.
Once again, we are sorry that you found this coin to be over appraised.
Sincerely,
Valued Change Sales Manager
Valued Change
PO Box 1431
Rustburg, VA 24588
Buy and Sell on USA Coin Book
Site Information
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin© 2010 - 2024 USA Coin Book. All Rights Reserved.