AC Coins, Currency & Collectibles Store - Buffalo Nickels

1917-P Buffalo Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$9.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$2.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$3.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1921-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$0.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1926-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1926-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1927-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$2.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1927-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1928-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1928-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$0.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1929-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1929-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1930-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$0.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1930-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1930-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1935-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$1.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1936-P Buffalo US Nickel • High Circulated Condition

$2.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1916-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated About Good/Good Condition

$7.50

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated

1916-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated About Good/Good Condition

$7.50

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated

1923-S Buffalo Nickel ~ Circulated Tougher Date AG/G Condition

$9.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated

1929-S Buffalo Nickel ~ Circulated Condition

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo Nickel ~ Circulated Condition

$2.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1918-D Buffalo Nickel • Dark Toned High Circulated Fine/Very Fine Condition

$69.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated

1915-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$9.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1915-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$9.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1916-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$6.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1917-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$6.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1918-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$4.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1918-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$12.50

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$4.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$5.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$12.50

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$14.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1920-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$5.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1921-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$3.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1923-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$2.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1924-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$0.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1924-D Higher Grade Mint Error Rotated Die/Reverse Circulated Buffalo US Nickel

Key Date 24D Buffalo Nickel

$24.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated/G+ Please Grade For Yourselves!

1924-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$17.50

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1925-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$5.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1926-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

$1.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1926-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

Slightly Rotated Reverse Die

$29.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1927-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1927-D High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$5.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1928-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1928-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1929-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1929-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1930-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1930-S High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1934-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1934-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1935-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1935-D High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$0.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1935-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1935-S High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1936-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1936-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$2.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1936-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1936-D High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1936-S Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1936-S High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1937-P Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1937-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.25

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1937-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Condition Pulled from Album

1937-D High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1920-P Buffalo Nickel • High Circulated Very Fine Condition

$9.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated

1938-D Buffalo Nickel ~ High Circulated Very Fine/VF20+ Grade

1938-D High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$2.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1919-P Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$0.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1920-P Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$0.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1920-P Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$0.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1920-D Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$8.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1925-P Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$0.79

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1927-D Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$8.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1928-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$2.49

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1928-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.49

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1929-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.49

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1935-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$0.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1935-S High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1936-S High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$1.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1937-P High Circulated Grade Buffalo US Nickel

$3.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Circulated - Please Grade For Yourselves

1920-P High Grade Circulated Buffalo US Nickel

Nice Earlier Date Buffalo Nickel

$0.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

1924-P High Grade Circulated Buffalo US Nickel

Nice Mid-Range Date Buffalo Nickel

$0.99

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

1936-S High Grade Circulated Buffalo US Nickel

Nice Later Date Buffalo Nickel

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

1937-P Higher Grade Very Fine/VF20+ Buffalo US Nickel

1937P VF BUSN$.05

$1.25

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: VF - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1925-D About Good/Good AG3/G4 Semi-Key Date Buffalo US Nickel

Appears to have rotated reverse

$2.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: AG/G - Please Grade For Yourselves!

1928-P Higher Grade Circulated Very Fine Buffalo US Nickel

1928P VF BUSN$.05

$4.99

or Best Offer

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

1929-P Higher Grade Circulated Very Fine Buffalo US Nickel

1929P VF BUSN$.05

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

1936-P Buffalo Nickel • Very Fine/VF25+

1936P VF25+ BUSN$.05

$1.50

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

1936-P Higher Grade Extra Fine/XF40 Buffalo US Nickel

1936P XF40 BUSN$.05

$1.75

Seller: 1currency1
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: Please Grade For Yourselves!

Store Search:

Shop By Price Range:

Buffalo Nickels

81 items found

Buy and Sell on USA Coin Book

Site Information

Follow USA Coin Book

Currency Converter

Switch View